Honeybee Foraging

Foragers dance longer for richer patches and idle bees follow a random dance, so the colony picks the best flowers.

  • Hive
  • Flower patch
  • Forager, patch color
  • Idle forager
  • Waggle run
  • Sun
100%

Foragers fly from the hive to the flower patches and dance for the richer ones; idle foragers follow a random dance. Drag a patch to move it, tap a patch to step its sugar, or tap open ground to add a patch, up to four; Rerun starts again from step 0 with the patches as you placed them.

Setup
300
Model
40 runs
20%
135°
View
60 steps per second

How is Honeybee Foraging working for you?

About Honeybee Foraging

Model
Dance recruitment among nectar sources (Camazine and Sneyd 1991)
Colony
50–600 foragers, up to four patches
Profitability
Sugar ÷ (1 + distance ÷ 1,000 m), a model setting
Dance floor
Waggle runs at their patch's angle from the sun (von Frisch 1967)
Default result
Over 90% of the foragers at work at the richer patch after 2,000 steps

Honeybee Foraging simulates how a colony moves its foragers to the richer flower patch without any bee comparing the patches. It follows the model Scott Camazine and James Sneyd published in 1991 alongside the feeder experiments of Thomas Seeley, Camazine and Sneyd on how colonies choose among nectar sources. A forager back from its patch unloads, then gives up the patch with a chance that falls as the patch gets more profitable, or dances for it, with a chance and a number of waggle runs that rise with profitability; then it flies out again. Idle foragers on the dance floor follow a random waggle run, so a patch recruits in proportion to its runs.

Profitability here is the sugar divided by 1 plus the distance in kilometers, so a 2.5 mol/L patch 400 m away rates 1.79 and a 1.0 mol/L patch at the same distance 0.71. At Dance length 40 the first earns 26 waggle runs a dance and the second 4; Seeley measured in 1994 how the number of waggle runs rises with a source's profitability. At the default settings the 2.5 mol/L patch holds over 90% of the foragers at work after 2,000 steps. With Swap the sugars on, the patches trade sugar at step 3,000 and the majority moves to the other patch within about 1,600 to 2,300 steps.

The inset shows the dance floor. Each dancing forager draws its waggle run as a line in its patch's color: straight up stands for the sun, the run's angle from vertical is the patch's direction measured from the sun's, and the run is longer the farther the patch, as Karl von Frisch described. Idle foragers wait there as gray dots. The chart follows the foragers at each patch, and the readout gives each patch's foragers, its waggle runs in the last 500 steps and the share of foragers at work at the most profitable patch.

How to use Honeybee Foraging

  1. Pick a preset. Two feeders puts a 1.0 and a 2.5 mol/L patch 400 m from the hive on opposite sides. Swap the feeders is the same with the sugars swapped at step 3,000. Near and far puts two 2.0 mol/L patches 200 m and 800 m away. Each preset starts a new run.
  2. Watch the colony choose. Foragers fly between the hive and their patch as dots in its color. On the dance floor at the upper right, dances for the richer patch are longer and more frequent, so idle foragers, the gray dots, mostly follow them.
  3. Change the patches. Drag a patch to move it; its distance and profitability change with it. Tap a patch to step its sugar from 0.5 to 2.5 mol/L, or tap open ground to add a patch, up to four.
  4. Tune the colony. Dance length sets the waggle runs for the best possible patch and Giving up the chance of abandoning a poor one; at Dance length 0 no forager is recruited. Sun direction turns every waggle run on the dance floor. The ? beside each setting explains it with numbers.
  5. Read the result. The readout lists each patch's sugar, distance, foragers and waggle runs in the last 500 steps, and the share of the foragers at work at the most profitable patch; the chart follows the foragers at each patch.
  6. Start again or export. Rerun starts again from t = 0 with your patches; Restart returns the preset's patches; Reset also returns every setting to its default. Save a PNG, record 8 seconds, or record 30 s from the start.

Frequently asked questions

How do honeybees choose which flowers to visit?

As a colony, without any bee comparing the patches. Each forager rates only its own patch: it dances longer for a more profitable one and gives up a poor one sooner, and idle foragers follow dances at random (Camazine and Sneyd 1991; Seeley, Camazine and Sneyd 1991). In this simulation that moves over 90% of the foragers at work to the richer of two patches within 2,000 steps.

What is the waggle dance?

A run a forager makes on the comb, waggling its body, that points nestmates to a food source: the run's angle from straight up is the source's direction measured from the sun, and the run lasts longer the farther the source (von Frisch 1967). The dance floor in this simulation draws each run that way.

Why do bees dance more for better flowers?

Because a forager's dance grows with the profitability of its source: Seeley (1994) found the number of waggle runs rises with how profitable the source is. Here, at Dance length 40, a 2.5 mol/L patch 400 m away earns 26 waggle runs a dance and a 1.0 mol/L patch 4.

What happens when the better patch changes?

The colony follows it. With Swap the sugars on, the two patches trade sugar at step 3,000; foragers at the now-poor patch give up and dance less, foragers at the now-rich one dance more, and the majority moves within about 1,600 to 2,300 steps at the default settings.

Is this a scientific model?

It is a teaching model of the mechanism in Camazine and Sneyd's 1991 model. Its numbers are model settings, not measurements: profitability as sugar ÷ (1 + distance ÷ 1,000 m), foragers flying 5 m per step, 8 steps per waggle run and the chance that an idle forager follows a dance.

References

  1. von Frisch, K. (1967). The Dance Language and Orientation of Bees. Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.
  2. Camazine, S., & Sneyd, J. (1991). A model of collective nectar source selection by honey bees: self-organization through simple rules. Journal of Theoretical Biology 149(4), 547–571.
  3. Seeley, T. D., Camazine, S., & Sneyd, J. (1991). Collective decision-making in honey bees: how colonies choose among nectar sources. Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology 28, 277–290.
  4. Seeley, T. D. (1994). Honey bee foragers as sensory units of their colonies. Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology 34, 51–62.
  5. Seeley, T. D. (1995). The Wisdom of the Hive. Harvard University Press.